This article uses the following two anti-AA tropes to claim that AA does not work:
- Lance Dodes' claim that AA has a 5-8% success rate, which I have have dealt with four years ago in this blog, and which has been fully refuted in the article "Alcoholics Anonymous and The Atlantic: A Call For Better Science"
- That table in Handbook of Alcoholism Treatment Approaches which anti-steppers (such as stoners lying to themselves) love to bring out, which is also quite inaccurate (yes, I have already blogged about this table). Did I mention that its author, William R. Miller, has recently written a book telling alcoholics how to moderate their drinking which is, quite bluntly, a fool's errand.
